Re: Derivation by restriction wrt to type inheritance

> or perhaps misread and thought that Object was an element rather than a
> type).

Arrgghh! That's exactly what I did so thanks for clearing that out.

> As you know, when you restrict complex content you have to list all
> the elements and attributes that you want to *permit*. So having an
> empty complex type definition is equivalent to not allowing any
> content or any attributes.

Sure, this makes sence now....

> > 2) My second reason is because (from what I can understand) in the
> > above restriction the intent is to use person elements instead of
> > entry elements. Doesn't the rules on restriction say that for this
> > to be valid then the type of the person element must be derived by
> > _restriction_ from the type of the entry element. In this case the
> > type of the person element (Person) is derived by _extension_ from
> > the type of the entry element (Object).
>
> When you have a substitution group, the particle that refers to the
> head of the substitution group (i.e. the event element) is effectively
> substituted for an xs:choice that lists all the members of the
> substitution group. So effectively the List type is as follows:
>
> <xs:complexType name="List">
>   <xs:sequence minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="unbounded">
>     <xs:choice>
>       <xs:element ref="person" />
>       ... any other members of the entry substitution group ...
>     </xs:choice>
>   </xs:sequence>
> </xs:complexType>
>
> As you can see, you can validly derive by restriction to the
> personList content model from that expanded xs:choice, just by cutting
> out a few of the choices.
>
> So you can replace an element with an element from its substitution
> group no matter what derivation method was used to derive the type of
> the element.

Thanks again for clearing this out for me. I've read the spec about the
substitutionGroups but never really understood how it worked so this was a
big help. I can now see why Henry's example was indeed a valid
restriction.

Cheers,
/Eddie